Choosing the best soil for microgreens is one of the most important decisions you can make as a grower.
The medium you select directly influences germination, growth speed, flavor, yield, and even nutritional value. Many beginners assume that any potting soil will do, or that microgreens do not need fertilizer at all, but real world trials show otherwise.
From fortified blends that boost protein by over 40 percent to simple potting mixes that outperform expensive alternatives, the right soil recipe can make a measurable difference.
Whether you are growing at home or for market, understanding soil quality, texture, drainage, and nutrition will help you produce healthy, vibrant, and nutrient dense microgreens every time.
Growing medium options for microgreens
Soil and non soil media both work for microgreens, but they behave very differently in the tray. Soil is usually easy to find locally, whether you buy a premixed bag or the ingredients to blend your own. It lets you set tray depth as you like and works in shallow or deep trays. It holds water well, supports root anchoring, and provides pore space so roots can breathe. Many growers also prefer the look and flavor that come from soil grown crops. After harvest, spent soil is simple to compost which keeps inputs affordable.
Non soil options include fiber mats, synthetic mats, and water culture. These are lighter to carry, quick to load in trays, compact to store, and cheaper to ship. They are popular for live trays in kitchens because there is no risk of spilling soil. They also have a lower perceived pathogen risk when handled well. The tradeoff is that mats and water culture provide no inherent nutrition, so you must feed through the water to match the vigor and finish that a good soil can provide.
For most small farms and home setups the balance of cost, availability, and performance favors soil. Mats remain useful when portability and a clean harvest are the top priorities, such as restaurant service with live trays.
Key qualities of a good soil mix
A successful mix delivers three things at once. It must give strong seed to soil contact for even germination, it must drain freely to prevent saturated pockets, and it must still hold enough water that trays do not swing from soaked to dry between irrigations. Texture is central to all three. A smooth fine mix without sticks or wood chips lets roots explore quickly and leads to uniform height and color. At the same time the mix should include coarse structure so air can move through the root zone.
Several proven bagged mixes meet these needs. Growers consistently report good results with HP ProMix and Sunshine Mix number four, both of which include ample perlite for aeration. Happy Frog Potting Mix can also perform well. One important nuance is to avoid going too fine. ProMix BX for example is a finer germination grade. In dense microgreen trays it tends to hold more water and can tip the root zone toward anaerobic conditions. Farms that switched from BX to HP saw better drainage and fewer problems with overwatering.
Nutrition in the substrate matters in the final week before harvest. A light starter charge in a bagged mix helps, and a balanced organic fertilizer can elevate growth and finish further. The goal is a living but well aerated medium that supports fast roots and steady moisture without creating a swamp in the tray.
🌿 Recommended Microgreens Supplies |
Real world experiments and data
Findings from a fortified potting mix
One experienced grower tested a simple recipe built on a high quality potting mix such as ProMix HP combined with a balanced organic fertilizer. Gaia Green 4 4 4 was applied at roughly 30 to 40 grams per gallon of soil, with the lower end favored because ProMix contains a small starter charge. The grower ran a mineral and protein analysis on broccoli microgreens grown with this recipe and compared them to a local certified organic product grown without the same level of fortification. Vitamins were not measured in this test. Every measured nutrient was higher in the fortified crop. Protein was 41 percent higher. Iron was about 200 percent higher which is three times as much. The trays also showed a fuller look and stronger stature.
The same testing revealed limits on popular amendments. Worm castings above about one to two percent created more issues than benefits in dense trays. Heavy compost additions behaved similarly. The likely reason is that very dense sowing and high moisture give opportunistic microbes a head start. Keeping the core mix well drained and using a measured amount of a complete organic fertilizer produced cleaner consistent results. The grower also noted that chunkier HP grade with more perlite outperformed finer BX grade in these conditions.
This fortified approach proved versatile beyond microgreens. Using the same recipe in a large container, a single non spicy habanero plant grown in a northern climate produced more than 230 peppers in one season, which illustrates the vigor that a well balanced medium can unlock.
Yield test across four media
Another grower compared four media using green pea shoots. Seed was presoaked overnight and sown at nine ounces per tray. The schedule remained consistent across all treatments with planting on Monday and harvest the following week on Thursday which is about ten to eleven days. The four media were Sun Gro Professional Growing Mix, a fifty fifty blend of Sun Gro with commercial compost, Happy Frog Potting Mix, and straight peat moss.
Early observations already hinted at the outcome. The straight peat tray did not drain well and water pooled on the surface. The other three looked similar during growth. Final harvest weights told the story clearly. Sun Gro Professional Growing Mix yielded 19 ounces. The fifty fifty Sun Gro plus compost blend yielded 16.8 ounces. Happy Frog yielded 17.6 ounces. Straight peat moss yielded 6.75 ounces. The grower noted that the pea seed lot was not his usual variety due to a supplier error, but since all trays used the same lot the comparison remained valid. The conclusion was that a reliable basic potting mix outperformed both a compost heavy blend and a premium potting mix in this context, while straight peat was not suitable because of drainage problems.
DIY soil mix recipe for microgreens
A simple blend that mirrors what works in practice uses three parts.
First use 70 to 75 percent coconut coir or peat moss. This forms the backbone of the mix, giving roots a fine matrix to anchor into and holding moisture evenly across the tray. If you choose peat, remember that it is acidic, so add agricultural lime to bring the pH closer to neutral.
Second add 20 to 25 percent perlite or vermiculite. This creates air space and improves drainage so the root zone stays oxygenated. Perlite tends to keep the mix lighter and freer draining, while vermiculite holds a bit more water. Either can work, and the choice can be tuned to your climate and watering routine.
Third include 5 to 10 percent finished compost. Compost supplies a gentle background of minerals and organic matter. The emphasis is on finished and high quality. Incomplete compost can carry unwanted microbes into a warm humid environment. Keep the proportion modest and aim for even distribution in the mix.
Blend thoroughly, then test moisture behavior in a single tray before scaling up. The goal is a surface that accepts water evenly, drains through without puddling, and stays lightly moist rather than saturated. Pair the mix with measured watering, steady airflow, and sensible humidity to minimize disease pressure.
Common misconceptions and lessons learned
A common belief is that microgreens do not need fertilizer. It is true that seeds contain enough reserves to germinate and push cotyledons, but the finish you see at harvest depends on available nutrition in the root zone. Side by side data showed that a balanced organic fertilizer in a well drained mix increased protein by 41 percent and iron by about 200 percent in broccoli microgreens compared to a similar crop without that input. In other words, not needing fertilizer to sprout is not the same as not benefiting from it.
Another lesson is that more compost or more worm castings does not always mean better growth. In dense trays, going above one to two percent worm castings led to more problems. Heavy compost blends also reduced yields in a direct comparison with a straightforward potting mix. These results align with the idea that microgreens thrive in a clean aerated environment with measured nutrition rather than a biologically hot substrate.
Media texture matters as much as ingredients. Finer germination mixes hold more water. In microgreens that can lead to overwatering and low oxygen at the roots. HP grade mixes with more perlite improve drainage and reduce those risks. Straight peat underperformed badly because it held water on the surface and restricted airflow.
Finally, non soil media have their place, but they supply no inherent nutrients. Anyone choosing mats or water culture should plan a feeding program through the irrigation water to reach the same vigor and finish that a balanced soil mix can deliver.
Practical recommendations for choosing soil
For those new to growing microgreens, the simplest path is to begin with a proven commercial potting mix. Options like ProMix HP, Sunshine Mix number four, or Sun Gro Professional Growing Mix have been tested in practice and consistently provide good drainage and aeration. They are widely available, cost effective, and forgiving for beginners.
Growers who want to improve nutritional outcomes can introduce a balanced organic fertilizer such as Gaia Green 4 4 4. A modest addition of thirty to forty grams per gallon of soil was shown to raise protein content by more than forty percent and iron content by about two hundred percent in broccoli microgreens. It is important to keep the amount moderate since some commercial mixes already include a small starter charge.
There are also some clear practices to avoid. Straight peat moss has poor drainage and leads to weak growth. Heavy use of compost or worm castings can cause problems with pathogens or reduce yields. Worm castings in particular should not exceed one to two percent of the mix. Very fine textured germination mixes also hold too much water and can suffocate roots. Choosing a chunkier mix with good perlite content prevents this.
For situations where cleanliness and portability are more important than nutrition or cost, mats can be useful. They are easier to transport, keep trays lighter, and provide a soil free surface for chefs who want to cut live trays in kitchens. In these cases, plan to add nutrients through the irrigation water, because mats alone offer none.
Overall the most reliable approach is to start with a clean, well aerated soil mix, use fertilizer in moderation, and avoid extremes. With this foundation microgreens will grow uniformly, harvests will be consistent, and nutrient content will be maximized.